{"id":485,"date":"2024-12-06T15:45:58","date_gmt":"2024-12-06T16:45:58","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/howtobigisland.com\/?p=485"},"modified":"2025-01-21T16:29:38","modified_gmt":"2025-01-21T16:29:38","slug":"the-state-of-gtm-jobs-customer-success","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/howtobigisland.com\/index.php\/2024\/12\/06\/the-state-of-gtm-jobs-customer-success\/","title":{"rendered":"The State of GTM Jobs: Customer Success"},"content":{"rendered":"
\n

Hello and welcome to The GTM Newsletter by GTMnow <\/strong>\u2013 read by 50,000+ to scale their companies and careers. GTMnow shares insight around the go-to-market strategies responsible for explosive company growth. GTMnow highlights the strategies, along with the stories from the top 1% of GTM executives, VCs, and founders behind these strategies and companies.<\/em><\/p>\n

\n
\n<\/div>\n

The State of GTM Jobs: Customer Success<\/h2>\n

At the crossroads of retention and revenue, Customer Success (CS) is a cornerstone for sustainable growth and is growing in both scope and importance.<\/p>\n

This can be seen from hiring trends and also industry prominence. For example, a Chief Customer Officer Summit was hosted for the first time at SaaStr Annual this year.<\/p>\n

This is the second part of our State of GTM Jobs series (read Part 1 about Sales on GTMnow<\/a> or Substack<\/a>). Special thanks to Jason Saltzman<\/a> and Live Data Technologies<\/a> for sharing access to real-time job change data for over 88 million professionals, revealing critical trends across customer success and go-to-market teams.<\/p>\n

Another very special thank you to contributors for directly sharing insight and perspectives for this publication: John Gleeson<\/a> (Founder & GP of Success Venture Partners \/ Co-Founder of Customer Success Meetup), Abbas Haider Ali<\/a> (VP Customer Success at GitHub), Amy Oilman<\/a> (SVP of Customer Success at Conversica), Andy Mowat<\/a> (VP of Revenue Operations at Carta), Eliot Offutt<\/a> (VP Customer Onboarding at Forma.ai), Elena Hutchison<\/a> (Founder of Up\/Right Analyst Relations), Mark Kosoglow<\/a> (Co-founder and CEO at Operator), Scott Gifis<\/a> (CEO at NoFraud), Neil Weitzman<\/a> (Founder & Fractional CRO \/ GTM Operator at revenue\u2022x), Richard Harris<\/a> (Founder of The Harris Consulting Group), Rita Jhaveri<\/a> (CEO at CX Growth Advisors), Justin Strackany<\/a> (Sr. Director of Customer Success at Decisions), Marko Buric<\/a> (Head of Cloud Customer Experience, Bay Area Enterprise at Google), Joanna Johnston<\/a> (SVP Customer Success at Gong), and Erin Guagenti<\/a> (VP of Customer Success at Productiv).<\/p>\n

Let\u2019s get into it.<\/p>\n

\n
\n<\/div>\n

Customer Success is on the rise<\/h3>\n

Let\u2019s start with a simple, but crucial insight: Customer Success is growing, and the demand for these roles is becoming increasingly evident. As shown by hiring trends, CS roles are steadily on the rise, with a clear shift towards prioritizing retention and expansion over new customer acquisition.<\/p>\n

\n
<\/p>\n
\"\"<\/p>\n
<\/div>\n<\/div>\n

<\/a><\/figure>\n<\/div>\n

This chart examines net arrivals and departure trends in customer success (CS) roles. The green bar represents net job arrivals, while the red bars represent net job departures. The purple line indicates the growth rate of retention and renewal roles as a percentage compared to January 1, 2022. A steady upward trajectory in the purple line signals consistent growth in the demand for these roles over time, with peaks and plateaus showing periods of acceleration or stabilization in hiring trends.<\/em><\/p>\n

Customer success roles are rising in volume. By late 2023 and into 2024, the earlier volatility stabilizes more than previous years. Despite fluctuations, the data shows steady growth in the importance and demand for CS roles. CS roles have grown as a priority, which can be equated to many factors, one of which being economic pressures pushing companies to focus on customer retention over new customer acquisition.<\/p>\n

It\u2019s a balanced, selective growth trajectory. Unlike the rapid expansion in Sales or Product, Customer Success hiring is stable and strategic, rooted in the need to drive retention and expansion revenue.<\/p>\n

Trends in seniority for CS hiring<\/h3>\n
\n
<\/p>\n
\"\"<\/p>\n
<\/div>\n<\/div>\n

<\/a><\/figure>\n<\/div>\n

This chart examines hiring trends across different levels of customer success (CS) roles, as indicated by the colors and labels.<\/em><\/p>\n

Companies are increasingly adding across all levels. The ratio of executive roles has decreased in comparison to more individual-contributor roles, though both are growing.<\/p>\n

A consideration around this data is that it is influenced by companies that are no longer growing at venture-backable scale.<\/p>\n

\n

\u201cMany startups have fallen out of the \u201ctriple-triple, double-double\u201d growth model that most go-to-market playbooks assumed for the past several years, which includes the baseline on which many Customer Success teams were structured. The reality now is that many companies no longer fit the venture-backed growth model and need to prioritize profitability. The primary ways to achieve this are by monetizing the post-sales motion or more closely aligning it with revenue.\u201d<\/em><\/p>\n

\u201cThere is also a separate category of companies experiencing true exponential growth\u2014AI companies, for example, which continue to raise at extremely high valuations, sometimes even before achieving product-market fit. For these companies, the traditional approach to Customer Success is still highly valuable: allocating extra resources to ensure customers find value in the product, delivering exceptional experiences, and building strong loyalty as they work toward product stickiness and repeatable, value-driven outcomes across their customer base.\u201d<\/em><\/p>\n

\u2013John Gleeson<\/a> (Founder & GP of Success Venture Partners \/ Co-Founder of Customer Success Meetup)<\/p>\n<\/blockquote>\n

Longer searches for CS professionals<\/h3>\n

The job search process in Customer Success is among the longest in the entire go-to-market stack. Why is this?<\/p>\n

\n
<\/p>\n
\"\"<\/p>\n
<\/div>\n<\/div>\n

<\/a><\/figure>\n<\/div>\n

CEOs making these hires consistently highlight that specialization has become a key priority since 2021. In the past, Customer Success roles tended to be more generalized across all levels, from individual contributors to senior leaders. Today, however, specialization has taken center stage, reflecting a shift in the demands and expectations of the role.<\/p>\n

The macro environment plays a factor, but it\u2019s the specialized skills being increasingly required that makes CS roles a longer more deliberate process.<\/p>\n

There is also a huge amount of ambiguity and conflation around CS roles and what specialization even means. Is it\u2026pre-sales? Post-sales? Onboarding? Retention? Engagement? Growth and expansion? Chasing down invoices?\u2026<\/p>\n

\n

Scott Gifis<\/a> (CEO of NoFraud) advises: \u201cThis challenge becomes even more pronounced as companies cater to different customer segments or profiles with varying needs. For example, an enterprise CS program requires a dedicated approach, but determining the right strategy for each account often involves complexities that are difficult to standardize until you achieve significant scale. On the other hand, a scaled CS program comes with its own distinct goals, systems, and operational challenges.<\/em><\/p>\n

The complexity grows further as companies consider their mix of products and potential services, adding another layer of nuance to customer success strategies.<\/em><\/p>\n

The key takeaway: start with a crystal-clear definition of the function\u2019s scope and avoid introducing unnecessary complexity too early in your journey. Additionally, ensure that your products and CX motions are designed to collect and act on data and signals effectively, enabling you to track impact and make informed decisions.\u201d<\/em><\/p>\n<\/blockquote>\n

Specializations and reporting structure shifts<\/h3>\n

The bifurcation+ of the CS role<\/h4>\n

One evolving trend in go-to-market is the bifurcation of Customer Success roles. Generally, there are two distinct paths:<\/p>\n

    \n
  1. \n

    The Revenue Model:<\/strong> Focused on expansion and renewals, this model is common for less technical, straightforward solutions that are easier to onboard. When CS operates under a revenue leader, there\u2019s a natural accountability to ensure customers succeed while fostering an understanding of winning the right customers with the right expectations. These teams typically carry revenue targets and must demonstrate measurable impacts on expansion and retention rates, especially in product-led growth (PLG) models.<\/p>\n<\/li>\n

  2. \n

    The Technical Model:<\/strong> Centered on support or professional services, this model often monetizes certain functions, particularly for highly technical or complex products. Under product leadership, CS gains a deeper understanding of customers and can focus on reinforcing value through the product experience itself. For labor-intensive, highly technical products, the connection to revenue may be less direct. Here, the focus is often on building deep, trust-based relationships rather than immediate revenue generation. In some cases, these teams shift toward monetized support and value-added service models, reflecting an increasingly common approach. This may be more product-centric, focusing on customer experience and customer journey. In this case, the advantage is a deeper understanding of the customers and how to ensure value is clearly reinforced through the product experience.<\/p>\n<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n

    The divergence in CS roles, moving either toward highly technical or highly revenue-oriented focuses allows for clear ownership of KPIs.<\/p>\n

    While they both come with their advantages, they also come with their challenges. For example, in a revenue model, a CS leader may be tasked with transforming a team from high-touch, white-glove support to a consultative approach emphasizing value realization and expansion. For this transition to succeed, the leader needs deep domain and industry expertise to effectively coach and guide the team in value discovery. Leaders without this background often struggle to make meaningful changes quickly.<\/p>\n

    In areas like security, infrastructure, and other highly technical products, CS roles increasingly require technical depth. Positions that might have been branded simply as Customer Success through 2021 now carry a broader range of titles.<\/p>\n

    Who should customer success report to?<\/h4>\n

    There\u2019s always nuance in organizational structures, influenced by factors like leadership dynamics, individual leadership skills, and go-to-market strategies.<\/p>\n

    That said, the prevailing consensus is that CS should report to the CRO if one exists. The reasoning is straightforward: the CRO owns revenue. Splitting responsibility across multiple leaders often results in fragmented ownership, where no one has clear accountability for the entire revenue flow.<\/p>\n

    It\u2019s like designing a menu. Just as an executive chef oversees the entire meal to ensure all the dishes complement each other, a single leader must own the full customer lifecycle to maintain alignment and cohesion. Without this unified approach, the \u201cmenu\u201d could fall apart, leaving the organization disjointed.<\/p>\n

    That said, there is always nuance. For example, Lattice, an HR tech company, made a significant structural shift about two years ago. They moved their commercial customer success team under marketing, separating it from the rest of the CS function and placing it under the Chief Marketing Officer (CMO). This change was driven by a predominantly digital-led motion, with Customer Success Managers (CSMs) playing a supporting role.<\/p>\n

    Another emerging trend is presales teams taking ownership of customer success. By having Sales Engineers (SEs) own both pre- and post-sale processes, and aligning their compensation and incentives accordingly, you address a long-standing challenge: the disconnect between a high-touch, high-value sales cycle and the subsequent handoff to implementation. When SEs remain responsible for ensuring the solution delivers on its promise and overseeing renewals, there\u2019s no ball to drop. This continuity not only strengthens trust with customers but also ensures the program consistently delivers the value that was sold. Having continuity between sales and customer success isn\u2019t new, Kustomer went from $0 ARR to a $1.2B acquisition with both rolling up to one leader<\/a>. In this shift, SE and CSM titles often get replaced with Customer Engineers.<\/p>\n

    While Customer Success organizations can look differently from company-to-company, one thing remains constant: The catch-all CS role previously filled by a non-technical, non-revenue-focused individual no longer exists. That was a \u201cZIRP-era\u201d phenomenon that has since disappeared.<\/p>\n

    The challenges around finding the right role for CS leaders<\/h3>\n

    Role ambiguity that can lead to broken models<\/h4>\n

    Many CEOs and CROs struggle to clearly define what a Customer Success team should do. This lack of clarity around the role\u2019s scope and priorities often leads to extended hiring timelines and misaligned expectations.<\/p>\n

    As such, Customer Success organization often wind up operating as a remedial team that fixes problems that originate in other departments. Because of this, it can be difficult to tell whether your CS org in particular is causing problems with your revenue. Abbas Haider Ali and others detailed three clear CS failure modes in this deep dive on how to identify if your Customer Success organization is broken and how to fix it<\/a>.<\/p>\n

    Though the root causes of each of these issues warrant their own posts, suffice it to say: if your CS team is operating in one of the below modes, they\u2019re focused on the wrong problem set.<\/p>\n